2026-11-17 · 6 min read · Warrenton
Should I Rent Out My Old House or Sell It? A Warrenton Homeowner's Guide
Should you keep your old Warrenton house as a rental?
If you are about to buy your next home, someone has probably told you to hang on to the old one and rent it out. It sounds smart. The house pays itself off, you build wealth, and you never have to say goodbye to the place where you started. For some Warrenton homeowners, that plan works well. For others, it turns into a second job they never wanted and a payment they cannot cover when the house sits empty.
I am John Meier, and I help people in Warrenton and across Warren County sell one home and buy the next. Clients ask me this question often. The right answer depends on four things: the monthly math, the local rules, the tax clock, and whether you need the money from the old house to buy the new one. This post walks through each one so you can decide with clear eyes.
Start with the monthly math, not the dream
The first question is simple. Will the rent cover every cost of owning the house, with room left over for the months when something goes wrong?
Public numbers give you a starting point, though not an answer for your house. The U.S. Census Bureau's QuickFacts for Warrenton city lists a median gross rent of $964 for 2020 to 2024, while the median monthly owner costs for homeowners with a mortgage come in at $1,343 over the same period. Those figures describe different homes, and census data runs behind today's market. Homes.com, for example, put the median rent for a home in Warrenton at $1,262 per month as of May 2026. Still, the gap between those two Census figures shows why you should never assume rent will cover your payment.
Build your own list before you decide. Your monthly cost as a landlord usually includes:
- Your mortgage payment, property taxes, and insurance
- A landlord policy, which is a different product from the homeowner policy you carry now
- Repairs, which arrive on their own schedule, like a water heater that quits on a Sunday
- Lawn care, gutters, and snow if the lease does not put those on the tenant
- Months with no rent while you clean, repair, and find the next tenant
- A property manager, if you do not want the phone calls yourself
If the rent only matches your payment, the house is not making money. It is borrowing from your savings every time the furnace or the roof needs attention.
The rules you take on as a landlord in Warrenton
Renting a house turns you into a small business owner, and the business has rules. A few of them are specific to Warrenton and Missouri.
The city inspects every new occupant. The City of Warrenton Building Department says an inspection by a city inspector is required whenever a new occupant moves in, and the residential inspection permit has to be issued before anyone lives there. According to the city's residential inspection guide, the $50 fee covers the first inspection and one reinspection, and each inspection stays valid for 90 days. If the inspector finds electrical, mechanical, or plumbing problems, the city says that work may need a building permit and a contractor licensed in Warrenton. Plan for this every time a tenant moves out, not only the first time. If your old house sits outside city limits, in Wright City, Truesdale, or out in the county, call that town or the county to learn what applies there.
Missouri limits security deposits. Missouri statute RSMo 535.300 says a landlord may not collect a security deposit greater than two months' rent. The same statute requires the landlord to return the deposit, or give the tenant an itemized list of damages, within thirty days after the tenancy ends.
Fair housing applies to you. The federal Fair Housing Act covers the rental of housing, not only sales. That law shapes how you write your ad, how you screen applicants, and how you pick a tenant. A homeowner renting a single house still has to get this right.
The tax clock most people miss
This part surprises a lot of homeowners, and it can cost real money. I am not a tax professional, so treat this as a reason to call one, not as advice.
According to IRS Publication 523, if you owned and lived in your home as your main home for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale, you may exclude up to $250,000 of gain from your income, or up to $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly. That five-year window keeps moving once you move out. If you rent the house for several years and then decide to sell, you may no longer meet the test.
Publication 523 also says that if you were entitled to depreciation deductions for renting the home, you cannot exclude the part of your gain equal to that depreciation for periods after May 6, 1997. In plain terms, the IRS can ask you to pay tax on depreciation later, even on a home you once lived in.
None of this means renting is a mistake. It means you should sit down with a tax preparer before you move out, not after. Ask them what happens if you rent for one year, three years, or ten, and what happens if you sell instead.
Do you need the old house to buy the next one?
Many move-up buyers in Warren County tell me the same thing: "We need to find the next place first." That makes sense. You want to know where you are going before you let go of where you live.
Ask yourself a hard question. Does the money tied up in your current house need to go toward the next one? If your equity is part of your plan for the next home, keeping the old house as a rental can leave you short. Your lender may also look at a rental differently than a home you are selling, so ask how keeping the house changes what you can buy.
When the numbers say sell, the goal becomes making the move once, in the right order. I walk clients through that sequence on my process page, from pricing the current home to timing the move into the new one. If you are still deciding where to go next, my Warrenton area guide covers the town, and you can browse current listings to see what is out there.
Questions to answer before you decide
Run through these with whoever you share the house with. Your answers will tell you more than any rule of thumb.
- Will the rent cover every cost on the list above, with money left over each month?
- Do you have savings set aside for a big repair and a few empty months?
- Do you live close enough to handle a leak or a lockout, or will you pay someone to do it?
- Are you comfortable screening tenants and following Missouri and fair housing law?
- Have you talked with a tax preparer about the IRS two-of-five-year test?
- Do you need your equity for the down payment on the next home?
- Would you buy this exact house today as an investment, at today's value?
That last question matters most. If you would not buy your old house as a rental at today's price, keeping it is the same decision. You are choosing to invest your equity in that property instead of somewhere else.
Talk it through before you move out
Some homes in and around Warrenton make good rentals, and some make more sense to sell. The answer depends on your house, your numbers, and how much of your time you want to give to it. I can tell you what your home would likely sell for today, so you can compare that figure to the rent and the work of being a landlord.
If you are weighing this choice, call, text, or email me through my contact page. We can look at your house, talk through your next move, and make sure there are no surprises along the way.