2026-05-14 · 4 min read · Warren County
Is Warren County, Missouri Still Affordable Compared to St. Charles County?
A question I hear every week
"Can we get more for our money if we look farther west?" I hear that a lot. Some of the buyers I work with grew up in Warren County. Others came out here after St. Charles County prices stretched their budget.
I'm John Meier with Westplex Real Estate in Warrenton. The short answer is that it depends on what you compare. Here are the real numbers I have, and how to line the two counties up yourself.
What Warren County homes sold for
These are from MARIS, our local MLS, for homes in Warren County that closed between October 29, 2025 and October 28, 2026. Houses, villas, condos and manufactured homes. Land isn't included.
- 663 homes sold, up from 574 the year before.
- Median sale price: $330,250, up from $320,000.
- Average sale price: $401,231, up from $395,914.
- Median days on market: 28, up from 19.5.
So prices are still inching up, but homes are taking longer to sell. Warren County isn't cheap anymore. It's a market where buyers have a little more room to look than they did a year ago.
How to compare it with St. Charles County
I don't have a matching St. Charles County number in front of me for the same dates, and I won't guess at one. Here's the fair way to compare.
- Same dates. Median to median, over the same 12 months. Ask me and I'll pull both from MARIS side by side.
- Same kind of house. Compare a three-bedroom on a quarter acre with a three-bedroom on a quarter acre. Lot size is where the two counties tend to look the most different.
- Your price range. Countywide numbers mix starter homes and big houses on acreage. What matters is what your budget buys.
Compare the whole cost, not only the price
The price is one number. What it costs to live there every month is another. Before you decide, compare these for each house you're serious about.
- Property taxes. Look up the current tax bill on the parcel with the county collector. Don't assume either county is lower.
- Insurance. Ask your insurance agent to quote the exact address.
- Utilities. City water and sewer, or a well and septic out in the county.
- Upkeep. A bigger lot means more to mow and maintain. I broke that down in what it costs to keep up acreage.
- Your commute. Time and fuel add up. Drive it at the hour you'd really drive it, from the house, not from the exit.
Start with your own number
The best way to know what's affordable is to know your own budget first. Talk to a lender about pre-approval and ask what payment you're comfortable with, not only the most you can borrow. If this is your first home, my Buyer's Handbook walks through the steps, and first-time buyers covers how I help.
Then look at what that budget buys in Warrenton and the towns around it.
Let's run the numbers together
Tell me your budget and where you drive every day, and I'll pull the numbers for both counties so you can see the trade for yourself. There's no hurry. It's a big decision.
Call me at (636) 242-5365 or send me a message.